Workers Compensation

Understanding Loss of Earnings Capacity for Fair Compensation

close up of woman holding up dollars.

Are you or someone you know suffering from an injury that has affected your ability to earn a living? If so, you may be entitled to compensation for your loss of earnings capacity. This legal concept is designed to provide financial relief to individuals who have been injured and can no longer earn the same income as before. As a leading personal injury law firm in Los Angeles, we have extensive experience helping clients with loss of earnings capacity claims. In this comprehensive guide, we will explain what loss of earnings capacity is, how it works, its history, who can benefit from it, and why it's important.

Warehouse worker past out on the floor after an accident.
Image by senivpetro on Freepik

What is Loss of Earnings Capacity?

Loss of earnings capacity is a legal term used to describe the inability of an injured person to earn the same income as before their injury. This loss can be due to physical or mental impairments resulting from the injury and can be temporary or permanent. The goal of loss of earnings capacity is to compensate the injured person for their reduced ability to earn a living, rather than just for their lost wages.

For example, let's say that before his injury, John was a construction worker earning $50,000 per year. However, due to a workplace accident, John suffered a permanent injury that prevents him from returning to work as a construction worker. As a result, John is only able to find work in a lower-paying job that pays $30,000 per year.

In this scenario, John's loss of earnings capacity would be calculated as follows:

Pre-injury earning capacity: $50,000 per year

Current earning capacity: $30,000 per year

Future earning capacity lost: $20,000 per year.

John would be entitled to compensation for his loss of earnings capacity, which would be based on the difference between his pre-injury earning capacity and his current earning capacity, as well as the future earning capacity, he has lost due to his injury. This compensation would help John cover his living expenses and provide him with financial stability despite his reduced ability to earn a living.

 

History of Loss of Earnings Capacity

Loss of earnings capacity is a relatively new legal concept that was first recognized in California in the 1970s. Prior to this, injured persons could only seek compensation for their lost wages, which did not consider their reduced ability to earn a living in the future. The concept of loss of earnings capacity was developed to provide a more accurate and fair way to compensate injured persons for the full extent of their economic losses.

The first case in California to apply the concept of loss of earnings capacity was Rodriguez v. McDonnell Douglas Corp., which was decided by the California Supreme Court in 1978.

In Rodriguez, the plaintiff was a 40-year-old airplane mechanic who suffered injuries to his neck and back because of an accident at work. The injuries left him with a permanent partial disability that restricted his ability to perform certain types of physical work. Prior to the accident, the plaintiff had been earning a good salary and had excellent job prospects, but after the accident, he was unable to continue working in his previous occupation.

The court recognized that the traditional approach to calculating damages, which only considered the plaintiff's lost wages up to the time of trial, did not adequately compensate him for his reduced earning capacity in the future. Instead, the court held that the plaintiff was entitled to recover damages for the loss of his ability to earn a living in the future, even if he had not yet suffered any actual loss of income.

The court explained that the concept of loss of earnings capacity recognizes that the ability to earn a living is an asset that can be impaired or lost because of an injury, and that compensation should be provided for this loss just as it would be for any other type of property damage. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to recover damages for his loss of earnings capacity, based on expert testimony regarding his future earning potential and the effects of his injuries on his ability to work.

This landmark decision set the precedent for future cases involving loss of earnings capacity in California and has been cited in numerous other jurisdictions across the United States. It is considered a significant development in the law of personal injury and has helped injured persons to receive fair compensation for the full extent of their economic losses.

Meeting of two people calculating numbers and filling a form.
Image by Drazen Zigic on Freepik

How Does Loss of Earnings Capacity Work?

To claim loss of earnings capacity, the injured person must prove that their ability to earn a living has been significantly reduced due to their injury. This requires a detailed analysis of their pre-injury earnings, their current earnings, and their future earning potential. The analysis considers various factors such as age, education, work experience, and the nature of the injury.

Once the analysis is complete, the injured person can seek compensation for their loss of earnings capacity. The compensation is calculated based on the difference between their pre-injury earning capacity and their current earning capacity, as well as the future earning capacity they have lost due to their injury.

Referring to the example previously stated, John would have to do the following:

1. Seek medical treatment: The first step is for him to seek medical treatment for his injuries. This will help document the extent of his injuries and the impact they have on his ability to work.

2. Document his pre-injury earnings: He needs to gather documentation of his pre-injury earnings, such as tax returns, pay stubs, and employment records. This will help establish his pre-injury earning capacity.

3. Determine your current earning capacity: Determine his current earning capacity by looking at his current job, or if he is unemployed, his ability to work in a different job or occupation.

4. Establish the nature and extent of his injuries: His injuries may have a significant impact on his ability to work, so it's important to document the nature and extent of his injuries with medical reports and expert testimony.

5. Calculate his loss of earnings capacity: Calculate his loss of earnings capacity by subtracting his current earning capacity from his pre-injury earning capacity, and then adding any future earning capacity lost due to his injuries.

6. Seek legal assistance: If he believes he is entitled to compensation for his loss of earnings capacity, it is recommended that he seeks legal assistance from a personal injury attorney who has experience with these types of claims.

7. File a claim: Once he has established his loss of earnings capacity, he can file a claim with the responsible party's insurance company or through the court system.

8. Negotiate a settlement or go to trial: The responsible party may offer a settlement to compensate him for the loss of earnings capacity. If he cannot reach a settlement, he might need to go to trial to have a judge or jury determine the appropriate compensation.

9. Receive compensation: If his claim is successful, he will receive compensation for his loss of earnings capacity. This compensation will help cover his living expenses and provide him with financial stability despite his reduced ability to earn a living.

Image by Freepik

Who Can Benefit from Loss of Earnings Capacity?

Anyone who has suffered an injury that has reduced their ability to earn a living can benefit from loss of earnings capacity. This includes individuals who have been injured in car accidents, slip and falls, workplace accidents, and other types of accidents. Loss of earnings capacity can also be claimed by individuals who have suffered from a medical condition that has affected their ability to work.

To list some examples of more detailed scenarios the following can be considered:

1. Car accidents: A person who has been injured in a car accident and can no longer work in their previous occupation due to the injury may be eligible to claim loss of earnings capacity.

2. Workplace accidents: A worker who has been injured on the job and is no longer able to perform the duties of their previous job due to the injury may be eligible to claim loss of earnings capacity.

3. Slip and fall accidents: A person who has been injured in a slip and fall accident and is no longer able to work in their previous occupation due to the injury may be eligible to claim loss of earnings capacity.

4. Medical conditions: A person who has developed a medical condition, such as a chronic illness or disability, that has affected their ability to work may be eligible to claim loss of earnings capacity.

5. Professional athletes: A professional athlete who has suffered an injury that has reduced their ability to perform at their previous level may be eligible to claim loss of earnings capacity.

6. Business owners: A business owner who has suffered an injury that has affected their ability to manage or run their business may be eligible to claim loss of earnings capacity.

7. Future earning potential: A person who has suffered an injury that has not yet affected their current income but is likely to do so in the future may be eligible to claim loss of earnings capacity.

These are just a few examples, and there are many other situations where loss of earnings capacity may be applicable. It is important to consult with a qualified attorney to determine whether loss of earnings capacity can be claimed in a particular case.

 

Why is Loss of Earnings Capacity Important?

Loss of earnings capacity is important because it provides a fair and just way to compensate injured persons for their reduced ability to earn a living. Without this legal concept, injured persons would only be able to seek compensation for their lost wages, which would not provide adequate relief for their economic losses. Loss of earnings capacity also helps to ensure that injured persons can continue to support themselves and their families despite their injuries.

 

Closing Statement

In conclusion, loss of earnings capacity is a legal concept designed to compensate injured persons for their reduced ability to earn a living. If you have been injured and your ability to earn a living has been affected, you may be entitled to compensation for your loss of earnings capacity. As a leading personal injury law firm in Los Angeles, we can help you understand your rights and seek the compensation you deserve. Contact us today for a free consultation.

Credits: Main Photo by Alexander Grey on Unsplash.

FAQ's

Decorative
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Tell Mendez & Sanchez About Your Case.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Let's Get
in Touch
Opening
hours
Monday-Friday
8am - 5pm
Personal Injury California
Personal Injury
Nevada
Workers'
Compensation California

Thank you for choosing our personal injury website. To address your legal inquiry effectively, please provide detailed information about your case in the form below. Expect a prompt response within one business day. We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to assisting you.

Thank you! Your submission has been received.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
TEXT USCALL US
Text UsCall Us
Available 24/7  |  Hablamos Español
Chamber of Commerce Badge