6 Reasons Insurance Companies Will Investigate Your Claim

Insurance employee typing on a laptop.

Table of Contents

I. Introduction

II. Reason 1: Getting to Know You Through Social Media

III. Reason 2: They Want To Know How the Accident Happened

IV. Reason 3: They Want To Gauge the Amount of Damage

V. Reason 4: Family, Friends, and Coworkers May Be Investigated, Too

VI. Reason 5: They Want to Know If You're Telling the Truth

VII. Reason 6: They Will Want to Know How Long It Will Take for You to Recover

VIII. Conclusion



Picture this: You're walking down a sunny sidewalk, minding your own business, when suddenly, an unforeseen accident strikes, leaving you injured and in pain. It's not your fault, and you shouldn't have to bear the burden of medical bills and lost wages caused by someone else's negligence. If you're nodding your head, knowing exactly what we're talking about, then listen closely, because this article is for you.

When life throws you a curveball in the form of an injury due to another person's carelessness, seeking compensation from the at-fault party's insurance company might seem like the obvious next step. You've seen those commercials promising justice and compensation, but you might wonder, "What's the catch?" Well, here's the thing – the amount of compensation you may receive is like diving into a treasure chest with varying prizes. It could be as little as a patch-up for minor injuries, like stitches from a clumsy fall, or a substantial fortune to cover extensive damages, such as multiple fractures after a serious accident.

But here's the kicker: Making that claim isn't a walk in the park. The insurance company representing the negligent party won't be sending you a bouquet of flowers or a fruit basket to apologize for the inconvenience. Oh no! Brace yourself, because they're coming at you with an investigation. That's right, they'll be digging into your life, your injuries, and your every move like Sherlock Holmes on a high-stakes case.

Why do they do this, you ask? Simple, it's a game of odds. They know that if they dig deep enough, there's a chance they can find something to downplay your claim or, worse, deny it altogether. Statistics don't lie – every year, a staggering number of injury claims meet their unfortunate demise in the face of these insurance company investigations.

But fear not, intrepid reader, because we've got your back! Welcome to Mendez & Sanchez Law, where we don't back down from a challenge. Our team of legal heroes, based right here in the heart of Los Angeles, California, has seen it all and fought it all. We live for the thrill of taking on the insurance giants and securing rightful compensation for our clients.

In this gripping article, we're going to unravel the mystery of injury claims and the tactics used by insurance companies to tip the scales in their favor. Armed with knowledge and determination, you'll be better prepared to face their scrutiny and emerge victorious. And when the going gets tough, remember, we're just a phone call away, ready to join forces and champion your cause. So, let's embark on this adventure together, securing the justice you deserve every step of the way. Are you in? Let's go!

Man looking with a magnifying glass
Image by Tumisu from Pixabay

Reason 1: Getting to Know You Through Social Media

In today's digital age, the vast realm of the Internet holds a treasure trove of private information, and insurance companies aren't shy about using it to get an inside look at the person behind the claim. Your social media activity, whether it's on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, or even reviews on platforms like Yelp, can all become crucial puzzle pieces in their investigation.

Here's where it gets interesting, and potentially nerve-wracking – those posts and updates you thought were just harmless fun? The insurance company might see them in a different light. Any content that portrays you in a negative or unfavorable way, like posts containing foul language or questionable behavior, will come under the insurance company's keen scrutiny.

But don't panic just yet, because there's a silver lining in this digital storm. Remember that looking bad online can actually work in your favor in certain situations. How, you ask? Well, if your posts happen to be about the at-fault party, like venting about a car too big for a tiny parking lot that ended up causing your injury, it could potentially make the insurance company more receptive to your claim. The logic behind this is surprisingly straightforward – in such cases, you were merely expressing frustration and not trying to profit from the situation.

So, how can you use this information smartly? First and foremost, be cautious about what you post on social media during the claims process. Consider adjusting your privacy settings to limit access to your personal information. It's essential to think twice before hitting that "post" button, as even innocent-seeming content could be twisted out of context.

Now, let's talk about social media as a double-edged sword. On one side, it can provide valuable evidence to support your claim, such as posts about the accident and its consequences. These can help paint a vivid picture of your situation and the impact it had on your life. On the other side, careless or unfavorable content can cast doubts on your credibility and potentially harm your claim's chances.

Social media icons on the screen.
Image by Pixelkult from Pixabay

Reason 2. They Want To Know How the Accident Happened

An insurance company's quest for information doesn't stop at merely knowing more about you; they are also determined to unravel the mystery behind the accident itself. Through covert investigations and thorough searches of public records and social media, they seek valuable insights into the circumstances that led to the unfortunate event.

Uncovering crucial details about the accident can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, if their investigation reveals that the at-fault party was driving recklessly or engaged in negligent behavior, it can significantly strengthen your claim for a higher settlement. This evidence could tip the scales in your favor, ensuring that you are rightfully compensated for the damages incurred.

However, it's essential to be aware of the other side of this investigation. Insurance companies are skilled at finding any possible information that may contradict or undermine your claim. If they discover that you were, in fact, at fault for the accident, they might use this revelation as grounds to reject your claim entirely.

Make no mistake; insurance companies are relentless when it comes to avoiding financial responsibility for accidents. They meticulously explore every possibility to avoid paying a claim, and their investigators are skilled at piecing together the puzzle of what really happened.

In this high-stakes game, being truthful and transparent about the circumstances surrounding the accident is paramount. Hiding information or attempting to manipulate the truth could prove disastrous for your claim. Instead, work with an experienced attorney who understands the complexities of insurance investigations. An attorney can help you navigate the process, ensuring you provide accurate and reliable information while protecting your rights.

Woman holding her chin in question.
Image by Robin Higgins from Pixabay

Reason 3. They Want To Gauge the Amount of Damage

When it comes to assessing a personal injury claim, insurance companies take their role as the gatekeepers of compensation seriously. They are determined to gauge the extent of the damage and determine a fair and accurate settlement. From medical expenses to property damage, every aspect of the claim is subject to scrutiny.

If you're claiming a shoulder injury, get ready for the insurance company's eagle-eyed assessment of your total medical costs. They'll leave no X-ray unturned and no medical bill unexamined. Similarly, in cases involving car accidents, they'll dig deep to determine the precise cost of a new car, evaluating the make, model, year, and condition.

Why do they go through all this trouble? The answer is simple – insurance companies aim to strike a delicate balance. They want to provide the injured party with just compensation, but they also want to avoid overpaying. This approach ensures that their resources are allocated efficiently while making sure you receive a payout that reflects the true value of your damages.

By conducting thorough investigations, they can quickly arrive at a well-founded compensation amount, ensuring that you are neither undercompensated nor granted an excessive sum. This meticulous process not only safeguards the company's financial interests but also promotes a sense of fairness and equity in the claims process.

Coins stacked in a white background
Image by Kevin Schneider from Pixabay

Reason 4. Family, Friends, and Coworkers May Be Investigated, Too

Insurance companies also scrutinize your relatives, friends, and coworkers who may have knowledge of the accident and its aftermath. The prevalence of communication in the digital age, facilitated by social media, means that information about your accident can quickly spread beyond just your immediate circle. As a result, the insurance company may extend its investigations to these individuals, seeking to learn more about your activities and compliance with medical advice, among other things.

Given this comprehensive approach to investigation, it's essential to approach telling others about the accident with caution. Here's a valuable tip: Be mindful of the information you share and who you share it with. While seeking support from loved ones and colleagues is natural, it's crucial to avoid oversharing sensitive details that could be used against you during the claims process.

Consider having private conversations with those closest to you and involved in your support network. Limiting the dissemination of detailed information about the accident and your injuries can help protect your claim's integrity and ensure that the information used by insurance investigators is accurate and relevant.

Reason 5. They Want to Know If You're Telling the Truth

Yes, insurance companies are diligent in verifying the truthfulness of your injury claims. The consequences of lying can be severe, as insurance fraud is a serious crime. According to statistics, insurance fraud costs insurers billions of dollars annually, impacting the entire insurance industry and leading to increased premiums for honest policyholders.

To ensure the accuracy of your claim, insurance companies may conduct extensive investigations, and one of the primary areas they scrutinize is your medical history. They will meticulously go through your medical records, seeking any previous injuries or conditions that may be relevant to your current claim. If they find inconsistencies or discrepancies between your claimed injuries and your medical records, it can raise red flags, potentially jeopardizing your claim.

Lying during a claim can take various forms, and it's essential to understand the consequences. For instance, some individuals may exaggerate the severity of their injuries, hoping for a larger payout. Others might even manufacture entirely false injuries to exploit the system. Regardless of the method used, if the injuries you claim do not align with the actual accident that occurred, insurance companies will be quick to notice and investigate further.

When it comes to personal injury claims, honesty is the best policy. It's crucial to provide accurate and truthful information about your injuries and their impact on your life. Any attempt to deceive the insurance company will likely be discovered during their investigations, leading to potential denial of your claim and even legal repercussions.

Sign showing double words Lie and Truth words
Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay

Reason 6. They Will Want to Know How Long It Will Take for You to Recover

In the intricate dance of insurance investigations, one crucial factor insurance companies are keen to assess is the duration of your injury and the anticipated recovery time. This information holds significant weight in determining the appropriate compensation for your claim. The longer it takes for you to recover, the higher the potential payout becomes, as it accounts for additional medical expenses, lost wages, and potential long-term impacts on your life.

However, insurance companies are not blind to suspicious patterns. If you submit a claim for a sprained ankle and then attempt to file another claim for a knee sprain a year later, they will undoubtedly raise an eyebrow. Inconsistencies and delayed claims can trigger alarm bells, leading the insurance company to closely scrutinize the legitimacy of your case.

The duration of your recovery is not only critical for calculating the compensation but also for evaluating the credibility of your claim. Insurance companies want to ensure that you are following the correct procedures and adhering to your doctor's instructions. They need to be confident that your injury is genuine and not the result of intentional actions to prolong the injury and inflate the payout.

For example, if your knee sprain takes considerably longer to heal than initially expected, the insurance company may delve into your medical records and treatment history. They'll examine whether you have been faithfully following your prescribed treatment plan or engaging in activities that might hinder your recovery. This thorough investigation helps them ascertain the legitimacy of your claim and protects against fraudulent practices.

Man checking his watch while using a laptop.
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio


The above are just some of the things that an insurance company will do to investigate an injury. However, there are many other things that they will do as well. For example, insurance companies will try and find out why the accident happened to begin with. If there is any suspicion that the at-fault party was driving under the influence, then they will investigate all of this.

Being honest about the accident is crucial to establishing that you were not at fault. Therefore, it is important to maintain the truthfulness of your statements throughout the claims process. Failing to do so may jeopardize your chances of receiving the appropriate compensation. To improve the likelihood of success in your claim, it is strongly advised to seek the assistance of skilled attorneys. They can guide you through the claim process, ensuring that you provide all necessary information and receive the compensation you are entitled to. With their help, you can get back to your worry-free life as soon as possible.

Mendez & Sanchez Law offers professional attorneys that can help individuals properly navigate the complex landscape of law. If you are looking for an accident lawyer in CA, get in touch with us today!


Insurance companies may use your social media activity to assess your credibility and the validity of your claim. Posts or updates that portray risky behavior, contradict your reported injuries, or suggest dishonesty can be used as evidence against your claim.

During a personal injury claim, it's best to avoid sharing detailed information about the accident, injuries, or your recovery process on social media. Limiting access to your profiles and being cautious about what you post can help protect your claim.

If the insurance company discovers discrepancies between your claimed injuries and your medical records, it may raise doubts about the legitimacy of your claim. This could lead to the denial of your claim or lower compensation.

Yes, insurance companies may investigate individuals close to you who have knowledge of the accident. They may examine their social media activity and communication to gather more information about your injuries and activities after the accident.

Honesty about the duration of your recovery is essential for accurate compensation. If the insurance company suspects that you are exaggerating or extending your injury intentionally, it can negatively impact your claim's outcome and even lead to legal repercussions.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Tell Mendez & Sanchez About Your Case.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Let's Get
in Touch
8am - 5pm
Personal Injury California
Personal Injury
Compensation California

Thank you for choosing our personal injury website. To address your legal inquiry effectively, please provide detailed information about your case in the form below. Expect a prompt response within one business day. We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to assisting you.

Thank you! Your submission has been received.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
TEXT USCALL USUpload your case
Text UsCall Us
Available 24/7  |  Hablamos Español
Chamber of Commerce Badge